From the category archives:

Oil Spill Remediation Discussion

One expert is calling on the U.S. government to nuke the Gulf oil spill. Christopher Brownfield, in an article at The Daily Beast, suggested that the government use nuclear or conventional explosives to “destroy the well and put the matter to rest.” Brownfield has experience with nuclear weapons; he’s a former nuclear submarine officer, an Iraq veteran, and a visiting scholar on nuclear policy at Columbia University. Brownfield says CNN reported last Thursday that the Russians used nuclear explosives on four separate occasions to seal runaway oil and gas wells underwater.

According to CBS News, at least one Russian newspaper has urged the U.S. to use nuclear explosives. What do you think of the use of nuclear explosives to close the BP oil well?

{ 39 comments }

We’ve had a number of responses to our request for suggestions to deal with the Gulf oil spill. Some were added in comments, and others were submitted via the Contact Form. Here are some of the submissions we received from people using the Contact Form: [click to continue…]

{ 76 comments }

UPDATED (see last paragraph and new link) – A reader named Bart wrote and said BP should consider using a proven method utilizing ground bagasse (a byproduct of sugar production from cane) infiltrated with ammonia to broadcast over sensitive wildlife areas where oil is washing ashore. According to Bart, the bagasse preferentially absorbs the oil and within a matter of weeks the hydrocarbons, with the aid of natural microbes and the nitrogen source, break down, eliminating the problem. Bart says it seems as though BP should welcome solutions such as this one. Bart tells us that CNN broadcast it on the news today, and says BP appears to be ignoring attempts to alert them to this additional remediation method. Finally, Bart said BP should be reminded by everyone possible to employ all available methodologies.

Thanks Bart. As I’ve said before, I’m a lawyer and don’t know enough about oil spill remediation to know a good idea when I see one. But we have readers who do know the subject matter. If anyone else has an idea that’s not being used, please send it along to us.

UPDATE: Bart sent us an email with an article discussing the use of bagasse to clean up oil. Here’s Bart’s email:

“Check this article describing the usefulness of bagasse (not to mention the huge quantities produced as a byproduct of sugar production) in clinging to oil while repelling water (hydrophobic quality).  A CNN spot was even a further modification of the bagasse- it had ammonium and microbial agents also embedded in it to speed up the conversion to small-chain hydrocarbons and eventually organic mulch, just what we will need in the sensitive ecotypes of coastal Louisiana and Mississippi.

What do you think of the feasibility of finding some organization to try this preemptively in a test area to prove to the corporate types that they should be purchasing all of this treated bagasse they can get their hands on and hiring crop dusting planes to be at the ready for the moment any of these oil slicks hit the bayous?  Would that be too proactive for our society? (Link to bagasse article).

{ 4 comments }

Shortly after publishing five unsolicited suggestions for dealing with BP’s Deepwater Horizon oil spill, we received another suggestion. Keith Schulz contacted us, gave us permission to post his name, and made the following suggestion:

“I work in the industry as a technical specialist and have an idea I would like to present. I am suggesting using a device we use called a clock spring to seal off the leak. This device is a spiral wrapped piece of metal which could be wrapped around the leak site and either slow or stop the oil from escaping. We have used this device for repairs on our pipelines and have had success. Please E-mail or call me if I can help assist.”

Keep sending ideas of ways to deal with the Gulf oil spill, and we’ll keep posting them. (here is a link to a picture of the Clock Spring Keith sent us):

{ 8 comments }

One thing that surprised me when I started this blog was that you, members of the public, have ideas about how to help solve the oil spill disaster and BP doesn’t want to hear about them. We’ve now gotten five unsolicited contact forms containing suggestions for stopping or preventing damage from the spill, and one person making the suggestion appears to have a good idea but says BP won’t talk with him. I’m a lawyer, not an engineer, so it may be that none of the ideas have merit, but I’m going to post the suggestions here and send links to some people who are involved in the cleanup effort. If you have an idea you think is worth considering, use our Contact Form and send it along. Social media is already helping pinpoint the damage and provide contact information for people who see injured birds and other things that need reporting. It would be nice if social media could give one member of the public a way to contribute one brilliant idea. I’m calling it “Crowdsourcing the Oil Spill.”

Here, contact information with those who have given permission, are your suggestions. If any agency or company working to stop the gusher or cleanup the oil wants to contact any of these people, I will be happy to provide their contact information.

1.  Mark Badger writes: “We have a way to contain the oil coming up from the seabed and we manufacture a boom system that far, far exceeds anything you have ever seen. 600 miles of it can be produced and deployed in under 30 days with current available materials.

Our boom sits a full three feet at water level and extends 8 feet under water and can be used as a containment system for animals as well in shallow waters like the Florida Keys. What are you going to do when dead manatees start washing up?

Our containment system for the well can be manufactured and deployed for complete containment in about 21 days. It is very simple to build, it will work in heavy seas, very simple to deploy and maintain. This system would allow the capture of ALL of the oil coming out of the well. It will even work in 50 foot seas and will withstand a hurricane.

We have tried to move our ideas forward to BP but we get no return calls or contact.

I can be called at 954-591-4298.”

2.  Ed M. writes: “Why not run tubing string inside recovery casing and inject steam. Haven’t done math but should be able to get effect of line heater.”

3.  Larry S. writes: “A suggestion to consider for preventing ice crystals.

1. Raise the dome.
2. Place a puncturable membrane on the bottom. (8 mil Visqueen)
3. Lower the dome 90 percent in the water.
4. Fill with automotive antifreeze.
5. Lower the dome back into position.

Hopefully, the majority of the antifreeze would remain in the dome during the descent.”

4.  Clive W. writes: “Isn’t it possible to use tankers equipped with oil /water separators to literally vacuum up oil on the surface of the water, extract the oil and pump filtered water back into the ocean ? The oil would then be stored in the hold and taken back to storage containers on land. The technology to do this already exists it’s just a matter of putting it all together.

It just might work as a temporary solution.

Just trying to help.”

5.  David C. writes: “Directors at British Petroleum , Honorable,Prudent,Beloved,Faithful. I have been a metal worker for many years. I have an idea to stop the oil but if you use it the idea you pay for my dentist bill 100% what ever I need. So my idea is to drill small holes, horizontal holes, in the existing well head pipe say, 1/4″ or3/8″. Then push steel rods into the holes like fingers. Keep on inserting the rods until you create a grid. Maybe you will have to go up and down the pipe with a series of rods. Then go about six feet down from the grid drill another hole big enough to inject golf balls. After that is done drill a hole in the middle of this mess of semi-jammed golf balls and inject a plastic epoxy into the middle under high pressure then the pipe would jam. Like some one in England once said, “jam yesterday, jam tomorrow but never jam today”. Good luck God be with you. Your friend David C….”

Do you have a brilliant idea to stop the leak or prevent damage to the ecosystem? Would you like for BP to pay your dentist bill (thanks to David C. for that idea)? Send your idea to us and, if it appears halfway reasonable, we’ll pass it along to someone with some authority.

{ 199 comments }

When social media first debuted, most people saw it as a way for indie musicians to bring their music to a larger audience, as on MySpace, or a way for college kids to invite each other to campus parties, as on Facebook. But savvy business people soon saw the potential for social media to provide a two-way dialogue between their public and often-inaccessible corporate suits. Corporate giants like Dell, Zappos, and Kraft Foods have embraced the power of social media, using this increasingly popular medium as a conversation tool with customers and the public. Now customers feel like they’re being heard by the companies they give their money to.

Well, except for some companies. Take our old friend BP.

Here at BP Oil News, we are, of course, covering the BP oil spill in the Gulf Coast with both Twitter (@bpoilnews) and one of the earliest types of social media – our blog. And though our blog is brand new, we found that within days of starting the blog, we were receiving suggested solutions from engineers and members of the public, including this one: [click to continue…]

{ 11 comments }